Design Review

Conduct comprehensive UI/UX reviews of web applications using Playwright for automated interaction testing. Produces structured implementation roadmaps for the creo-design-implement skill.

Commands

Command	Description
/creo design-review <url>	Full design review at all breakpoints
/creo design-review mobile <url>	Mobile-focused review (375px, 768px)
/creo design-review a11y <url>	Accessibility-focused WCAG AA audit

Core Instructions

Configuration

1. Check for project-specific config at .claude/project-config.md
2. Read dev_server_url (default: http://localhost:3000), ui_framework, ui_rules, reports_path
3. Load project extension if it exists at .claude/skills/creo-design-review/creo-design-review-{project_id}.md. This file contains project-specific rules, paths, design tokens, component standards, and domain knowledge. {project_id} comes from project-config.md. Always load it before doing work.
4. If no config exists, use defaults or ask user

Phase 1: Environment Setup

• Expected URL: read from project config, default http://localhost:3000
• Do NOT start the server -- expect it to be already running
• If server is not available, stop work and inform user immediately
• If MCP connection fails, close browser and retry navigation

Phase 2: Principle-Based Analysis

Evaluate the current implementation against design principles:

• Visual hierarchy and information architecture
• Component consistency and design system adherence
• Accessibility compliance (WCAG 2.1 AA)
• Responsive design and mobile optimization

Phase 3: Comprehensive Assessment

Use Playwright MCP tools for automated testing:

• Navigation: browser navigate to target pages
• Interactions: click, type, select for functional testing
• Screenshots: capture visual evidence at each breakpoint
• Viewport testing: resize to 375px, 768px, 1440px, 1920px
• DOM analysis: snapshot for structural review
• Console: check for errors and warnings

Phase 4: Implementation Roadmap

Create a prioritized task list:

• Blockers: Critical issues preventing functionality
• High-Priority: Significant UX/accessibility problems
• Medium-Priority: Visual consistency improvements
• Enhancements: Polish and optimization opportunities

Report Structure

# Design Review and Implementation Roadmap

## Executive Summary
[Current state assessment and principle compliance overview]

## Design Principles Analysis
### [Principle Name]
- Current State: [How well implemented]
- Gap Analysis: [What is missing or wrong]
- Impact: [User experience implications]

## Implementation Tasks

### Blockers (Critical)
- [ ] Task 1: [Specific action needed]

### High-Priority
- [ ] Task 1: [Specific action needed]

### Medium-Priority
- [ ] Task 1: [Specific action needed]

### Enhancements
- [ ] Task 1: [Specific action needed]

## Verification Screenshots
[Screenshots at different breakpoints]

## Next Steps
This report should be passed to creo-design-implement for systematic implementation.

Report Output

Save the complete report to: .claude/reports/design-review-[timestamp].md

The review is NOT complete until the report file is created and saved.

Reference Files

Load these on demand for extended guidance:

File	Purpose
references/design-principles.md	Design principles checklist
references/wcag-checklist.md	WCAG 2.1 AA compliance items

Quality Gates

• Every review must produce a written report file
• All four breakpoints (375px, 768px, 1440px, 1920px) must be tested
• Screenshots must be captured as visual evidence
• Issues must be categorized by priority level
• Report must include actionable tasks with specific file/component references
• Maintain objectivity while being constructive
• Balance perfectionism with practical delivery timelines