claude-forge Orchestrator

Step 1: Initialize or Resume

To resume a suspended pipeline, supply the spec directory name from .specs/:

Example: /forge 20260401-effort-only-flow

1. Call mcp__forge-state__pipeline_init(arguments=$ARGUMENTS).

2. If result.errors is non-empty: surface the errors to the user and stop.

3. If result.resume_mode is "auto": the input matched an existing spec directory. Do not ask for confirmation — proceed directly to Step 2.

4. For new pipelines (resume_mode is absent): a. If result.fetch_needed is non-null:

   1. Fetch the external data using the method specified in fetch_needed:
      • If fetch_needed.mcp_tool is set: call the MCP tool with fetch_needed.mcp_params.
      • Else if fetch_needed.command is set: execute the command via Bash and parse the JSON output.
      • Else: follow fetch_needed.instruction as a fallback guide.
   2. Map the response fields to external_context using fetch_needed.response_mapping: for each entry (response_key → context_key), set external_context[context_key] = response[response_key].
   3. Call mcp__forge-state__pipeline_init_with_context(workspace=result.workspace, source_id=result.source_id, source_url=result.source_url, flags=result.flags, external_context=<mapped data>). (task_text is not applicable for external issue sources — do not pass it.) b. If result.fetch_needed is null (plain text input): call mcp__forge-state__pipeline_init_with_context(workspace=result.workspace, flags=result.flags, task_text=result.core_text). (result.core_text is a top-level field in the pipeline_init response — the task text with bare flags stripped.)

   After the first pipeline_init_with_context call, check which field is present in the response:

   If result.needs_discussion is non-null (triggered only when --discuss flag is present, source is plain text, and --auto is absent):

   1. Present each question in result.needs_discussion.questions to the user via AskUserQuestion (single prompt listing all questions).
   2. Collect the user's answers as a single freeform string (e.g. "Q1: <answer>\nQ2: <answer>\nQ3: <answer>").
   3. Call mcp__forge-state__pipeline_init_with_context again (the discussion call) with: workspace=<same>, flags=<same>, task_text=<same>, discussion_answers=<collected answers string>. The response will contain needs_user_confirmation where needs_user_confirmation.enriched_request_body is non-empty.
   4. Proceed with the effort/branch confirmation step below using this needs_user_confirmation. When calling pipeline_init_with_context with user_confirmation, pass back: user_confirmation={effort: <confirmed>, workspace_slug: <slug>, use_current_branch: <bool>, enriched_request_body: needs_user_confirmation.enriched_request_body}. This carries the enriched request.md body forward to workspace initialisation.

   If result.needs_user_confirmation is present directly (--discuss absent, --auto set, or GitHub/Jira source): proceed with the effort/branch confirmation step below (no enriched_request_body to pass back).

   Effort/branch confirmation step (applies after either path above): Present all of the following to the user in a single prompt (use AskUserQuestion with multiple questions):

   1. Effort level: present all three effort options from effort_options (S, M, L — each with skipped_phases using the label field). Each option has a recommended boolean — mark the one where recommended is true as "(Recommended)".
   2. Branch decision: based on current_branch and is_main_branch from the response:
      • If is_main_branch is true: inform the user a new branch will be created (no question needed).
      • If is_main_branch is false: ask whether to use the current branch or create a new one. While waiting, generate a concise English slug (3–6 words, lowercase, hyphen-separated, ASCII only) that summarises the task — e.g. "add-user-auth-endpoint" or "fix-report-export-timeout". If the input is in a non-English language, translate the core intent into English for the slug. Do not include the issue number (GitHub #N or Jira PROJ-123) in the slug — the server prepends source_id automatically when present. Then call mcp__forge-state__pipeline_init_with_context again with the same parameters plus user_confirmation={effort: <confirmed>, workspace_slug: <slug>, use_current_branch: <bool>}. If needs_user_confirmation.enriched_request_body is non-empty (from the discussion path), also include enriched_request_body: <value> inside user_confirmation. The response will contain branch (the branch name) and create_branch (boolean). If create_branch is true: run git checkout -b <branch> via Bash immediately. Use the workspace from the confirmed response for all subsequent calls. Important: Always pass the workspace path from pipeline_init unchanged to the first pipeline_init_with_context call. Never construct workspace paths manually.

Step 2: Main Loop

Repeat until done:

1. Call mcp__forge-state__pipeline_next_action(workspace=<workspace>, previous_action_complete=true, previous_tokens=<tokens from last action>, previous_duration_ms=<ms from last action>, previous_model=<model from last action>, previous_setup_only=<setup_only from last action>). On the very first call, omit the previous_* parameters.

2. If result.report_result is non-null:

   • If result.report_result.next_action_hint == "revision_required": present result.report_result.findings to the user, then continue the loop. On the next pipeline_next_action call, omit previous_action_complete (or pass false), and pass previous_tokens=0, previous_duration_ms=0 with no previous_model or previous_setup_only — no new agent ran during this step, so P5 must not fire again. (setup_continue is handled server-side — the handler re-enters NextAction automatically.)

3. Execute the action based on action.type:

   • spawn_agent: If action.display_message is non-empty, output it verbatim. Then call Agent tool with action.prompt. Use action.agent as description. Record the tokens, duration, and model for the next pipeline_next_action call.
     • If action.parallel_task_ids is non-empty: spawn one Agent call per task ID in parallel; wait for all to complete before calling pipeline_next_action again.
     • Artifact write fallback: After the agent returns, if action.output_file is non-empty, check whether {workspace}/{action.output_file} exists on disk. If the file does NOT exist, the agent returned its output as text instead of writing the file (subagents may lack write permission in some permission modes). In that case, use the Write tool to write the agent's final response text to {workspace}/{action.output_file} before calling pipeline_next_action. This ensures pipeline_report_result artifact validation always succeeds.
   • checkpoint: Present action.present_to_user to the user. Mention that the Dashboard can be used to approve without terminal input. Then immediately call mcp__forge-state__pipeline_next_action(workspace) (no user_response, no previous_*). The server long-polls up to 50 s waiting for a Dashboard approval event.
     • If the response has still_waiting: true: call pipeline_next_action(workspace) again immediately (no user_response). Repeat until a non-checkpoint action is returned or the user provides a terminal response.
     • If the user types a response in the terminal (proceed / revise / abandon) while still_waiting is looping: on the next pipeline_next_action call, pass user_response=<response> instead of looping.
     • If a non-checkpoint action is returned: Dashboard approved; proceed normally.
     • Special: post-to-source checkpoint — when action.name is "post-to-source":
       1. Ask the user whether to post the work report (use AskUserQuestion with options "post" / "skip").
       2. If the user chooses "post" and action.post_method is present: a. Read the body content from action.post_method.body_source. b. Post the comment using the method specified in post_method:
          • If post_method.mcp_tool is set: call it with post_method.mcp_params and the body content (pass body as the body parameter).
          • Else if post_method.command is set: execute the command via Bash.
          • Else if post_method.instruction is set: follow the instruction as a fallback guide. c. Report success or failure to the user.
       3. If the user chooses "skip": do nothing. Pass the user's response to pipeline_next_action(workspace, user_response=<response>). Do NOT call checkpoint() — pipeline_next_action handles the checkpoint state transition internally. On every pipeline_next_action call for a checkpoint (still_waiting loops and terminal-response call alike), omit previous_action_complete (or pass false), and pass previous_tokens=0, previous_duration_ms=0 with no previous_model or previous_setup_only (checkpoints have no agent cost; omitting previous_action_complete causes the P5 block to be skipped).
   • exec: Run action.commands via Bash. Record the duration and action.setup_only for the next pipeline_next_action call. Pass previous_setup_only=true if action.setup_only is true. There is no model to record for exec actions; omit previous_model or pass it as an empty string. Also pass previous_action_complete=true (see Rules below).
   • write_file: Write action.content to action.path. Record the duration for the next pipeline_next_action call. Omit previous_model or pass it as an empty string. Also pass previous_action_complete=true (see Rules below).
   • human_gate: A task requires human action (e.g. merge an external PR, update dependencies). Present action.present_to_user to the user using AskUserQuestion with action.options.
     • If the user chooses "done" or "skip": call pipeline_next_action again with no previous_* parameters (no agent ran). The handler automatically marks the task as completed.
     • If the user chooses "abandon": call mcp__forge-state__abandon(workspace). Do NOT call checkpoint or phase_complete for human_gate actions.
   • done: Pipeline complete. Stop.

Supported Flags

• --auto: Skips all human confirmation prompts; progresses the pipeline automatically. Takes precedence over --discuss: when both flags are present, discussion mode is suppressed and needs_user_confirmation is returned directly.
• --discuss: Triggers a pre-pipeline clarification dialogue for plain text input pipelines. The orchestrator presents targeted questions to the user, collects answers, and writes the enriched task description into request.md before invoking any agents. Has no effect for GitHub/Jira source pipelines (external context already provides structured content) or when --auto is also set.
• --nopr: Skips the PR creation phase at the end of the pipeline.
• --debug: Enables debug mode in the pipeline state.

Flags can also be set as persistent defaults via /forge-setup. Explicit flags on /forge always override preferences.

Rules

• Never make orchestration decisions independently — follow action.type exactly.
• Always pass previous_action_complete=true, previous_tokens, previous_duration_ms, previous_model, and previous_setup_only on every pipeline_next_action call after the first (after any spawn_agent, exec, or write_file action completes). Do NOT pass previous_action_complete=true after a checkpoint — it must remain false (or omitted) to skip the P5 report block.
• When still_waiting: true is returned: call pipeline_next_action(workspace) again immediately with no previous_* or user_response. This is the Dashboard long-poll loop (50 s per iteration) — keep calling until a non-still_waiting response arrives or the user types a terminal response.
• Never pass isolation: "worktree" to any Agent call.
• On MCP error: surface the error to the user and stop.